Especially for Lawyers – Why So Many Wheelchair Tipovers, Part 5

There is no escape from wheelchair securement: Because denying disabled passengers transportation is not allowed, the only solution is to maintain a policy requiring wheelchair securement, maintain compliant equipment, to train drivers to proficiency, and to monitor their compliance and performance.

#wheelchairandpassengersecurement #wheelchairtipovers #publictransirtexpert #transalt

Read full post at TransAlt.com

In recent past posts, I mentioned some idiosyncrasies in the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) that accounted for many wheelchair tipovers – including the fact that one part of the ADA (49 CFR 37.165) does not even require their securement, while if one does so at all, the chair must not move more than two inches in any direction during a vehicle’s “normal operating conditions.”

As Americans (and likely people in countries throughout the world), we have become accustomed with clashes between various regulations and judicial rulings. One of the most curious of these related to the ADA is that while regulations for wheelchair securement are stringent (like 49 CFR 38.23(d)(5), which can only be complied with when securement equipment is “operational” and the driver is trained to use it, the ADA does not permit a provider of service to deny any disabled individual a trip (Liberty Resources v. SEPTA, PA, 2001). This prohibition of denial means, essentially, that if a wheelchair cannot be secured properly, while the provider’s policy is to require it, that wheelchair (and obviously its occupant) must transport it and its occupant regardless.

About this seeming dilemma, it is actually a genuine dilemma. But one can move in many directions in response to it. One might argue  that since every wheelchair user must be transported, with safe, compliant equipment or without it, the way to reconcile this dilemma is to endorse the policy of 49 CFR 37.165 of the ADA, and simply not bother to secure wheelchairs. Unfortunately, that approach bumps up against something known as the “industry standard,” which is almost always higher than any regulation (and certainly is in this case). And the industry standard is to prohibit a rolling chair to be carrier on a moving floor (or a chair-on-wheels on a transportation vehicles). And as a high industry standard usually carries  more weight in a civil court dispute than a minimal regulation, industry standards almost always prevail.

As an expert witness, I prevailed on this issue in a 2002 California case named Borja v. Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority, where the defendant’s policy was simply to not require wheelchair securement, but only that “a driver may ask” a wheelchair user if he or she would like his or her chair secured (49 CFR 37.165). After that lower court decision, almost every transit agency in the country retained or changed its policy to require wheelchair securement. So a reconciliation relying on 49 FR 37.165 clearly did not work. This lower court ruling verily changed the transportation landscape for wheelchair securement throughout the entire country, as almost every transit agency (or municipality or private contractor) retained or changed its policy to require wheelchair securement.

A reconciliation of this dilemma whereby a wheelchair is transported while secured with faulty, incomplete or otherwise non-ADA-compliant equipment will also not work and involves great risk. That is because transporting a chair with faulty, incomplete or otherwise non-compliant equipment is likely to cause a wheelchair to tipover – thereby violating the two-inch movement rule of 49 CFR 38.23(d)(5).

As securement according to this requirement is the industry standard, if one wishes to transport a moving chair on a rolling floor it must ensure that the chair not roll. This means that the securement equipment must be operational and fully compliant with section 49 CFR 38.23(d). That reconciliation clearly meets the industry standard.

In simple terms, the only way to reconcile this dilemma is to maintain securement equipment compliant with section 39 CFR 38.23(d) – and make sure to use it. Of course, with ADA-compliant securement equipment, there is no reason why a vehicle and its driver would not transport a chair except where a driver does not know how to use such equipment – on every and any type of “common wheelchair” (as it is defined in the ADA). To ensure that every driver does, the ADA includes a sloppy provision, that has often been debated, requiring that drivers be “trained to proficiency.” The weakness of this provision is, of course, that there is no universally acceptable definition of “proficiency.”

Nevertheless, there is only one way to reconcile the dilemma noted – to not deny any trips to any disabled passengers and to ensure their safety. In the case of wheelchair users, this means that (a) the transit agency’s policy (or that of a contractor or any other type of private company or public agency) must be to transport every wheelchair and its user, (b) to ensure that chair-and-user’s safety by maintaining equipment that is compliant with section 49 CFR 38.23(d), and (c) to train every driver to do so to a degree of proficiency. And the most rudimentary resolution of “proficiency” must be to secure every wheelchair to comply with the two-inch movement provision (subset (5) of section 49 CFR 23.23(d) of the ADA. Other than lucking upon a jury so inept as to not grasp the most basic understanding of inertial or centrifugal forces (at least at the conceptual level) and one that disregards the only reasonable interpretation of the industry standard for transporting a rolling chair on a moving floor – that interpretation being to secure it such that it barely moves in any direction during “normal operating procedures” (which include a driver slamming on his or her vehicle’s brakes) — there is no escape from the reconciliation last cited above: (a) Maintaining ADA-compliant equipment, (b) having a policy requiring drivers to use it, and (c) ensuring that they do.

For this last reason, apart from the vehicle running behind schedule in almost every wheelchair tipover scenario, wheelchair tipovers result almost always from the failure to meet these three criteria. In most cases, the Achilles heel is almost always a failure in monitoring – or a transportation system whose owner and manager do not care.

There is no escape from wheelchair securement: Because denying disabled passengers transportation is not allowed, the only solution is to maintain a policy requiring wheelchair securement, maintain compliant equipment, to train drivers to proficiency, and to monitor their compliance and performance.

#wheelchairandpassengersecurement #wheelchairtipovers #publictransirtexpert #transalt